Buy a multi pack and save $! First, consider the price. I paid $5.40 ON SALE for a small 2 pack that consisted of the pig & duck. I already know that the squeakers will be destroyed within minutes so I easily removed the one I could. It was nice that it was so easy to get to the bigger one in the head (though not for the dog). The other is sewed in. As a rule of thumb, I don’t spend more than $4-5 per toy (at most) because my basset bound teenager destroys all her toys. She loves to play w and squish water bottles but sometimes she goes too far and chews the plastic off which scares me. I know if the pieces are small, she shouldn’t have issues passing them being she’s a med size dog but it’s not good for her nonetheless because they won’t truly be digested. A larger piece could cause an obstruction or irritate her intestines, anus, cause choking or restricted airflow, etc. The last plush water bottle holder I bought for her was quickly destroyed and thrown away. I thought she’d do the same w these but so far, the one I’ve given her is still holding up perfect-minus the squeakers-albeit a little slobbery and dirty after 3 wks. The small size is perfect for her too. (She’s 50 lbs.) I thought it’d be on the smaller side which she seems to prefer so she can run fast and easily carry it. But it was bigger than I thought yet not too big so it was perfect. I like the way the Velcro is sewed and comes together so there’s no part for her to get started nibbling on and end up pulling it all apart. The Velcro has stayed nice and snug too w out attracting a bunch of hair. Surprisingly, she hasn’t been able to chew it open or rip it. She loves playing w her piggy and brings it to me to “fix” which means placing a new unsmashed bottle inside for her. The fabric is very durable considering it’s a cheap plush. Keep in mind that it’s still plush. You really can’t expect it to last that long when a dog is pulling, chewing, dragging it everywhere. My dog is barely above average destructive. I’d say a 6/10. She won’t destroy the carpet, doors, food bowls, etc like other dogs I’ve seen but all her toys are missing stuffing w rips and she’ll chew anything she can fit in her mouth. So I keep that in mind when leaving feedback about her toys vs the cost, etc. I’m very impressed w these plush water bottle holders and would recommend them to anyone who has average and realistic expectations for a cheap dog toy. As soon as they’re on sale again, I’ll be buying a multi pack (4 for $12/5 for $15) and give them as gifts to my four legged friends for the holidays.